“The cloud” is computing you rent from someone else’s data centre and reach over the internet. The US standards body NIST defines it as on-demand network access to a shared pool of computing resources that can be provisioned and released quickly. Whether that beats a server in your own office depends on the job you are asking it to do.
What changes hands, and what does not
With a server in the office, everything is yours to look after: the room, the power, the machine, the software on it and the data. Move to the cloud and the lower layers pass to the provider. Microsoft lists the physical data centre, the physical network and the physical hosts as its job in every kind of cloud service.
Some things never pass across. Microsoft, Amazon Web Services and Google all publish a shared responsibility model, and all three leave the customer responsible for their own data and for who has access to it. The Australian Signals Directorate puts it this way for small businesses: you carry the risk of your data being stolen, changed or lost, and you cannot outsource that risk to a provider.
How much passes across depends on what you rent. If you rent a whole virtual server, you still manage its operating system and its updates. If you rent finished software, such as an email service, the provider manages nearly everything underneath. The Directorate’s advice is to prefer services where the provider carries more of the security work, such as a hosted service in place of a web server you run yourself.
When the cloud is the right choice
- People work from more than one place. Files kept online can be reached from any location, and business.gov.au notes that several people can work on one document at the same time.
- Nobody on site looks after hardware. A server in the office needs space, IT support and regular hardware upgrades. Cloud storage needs none of those from you.
- The work goes up and down. Cloud services are charged by use, so you can add capacity for a busy season or a new hire and hand it back afterwards.
- The job is email, calendars or shared files. These come as finished services, with the provider running everything underneath.
- A purchase is due anyway. If the server is at the end of its life, renting saves buying a machine sized for needs you have to guess at.
When a server in the office is still right
- The software needs it. Some business applications are only supported by their maker on a local server, or have to talk to equipment in the building. Ask the maker before assuming either way.
- The files are very large. Video, drawings and scans all have to travel over the office internet connection every time they are opened or saved. On a slow connection, that is slower than a server down the hall.
- The connection is poor. Everything in the cloud stops when the internet does, and nbn says equipment connected to its network will not work during a power outage.
- The load is steady and the server is fine. Charging by use rewards work that varies. A machine that is supported, paid for and busy all day has less to gain. Amazon Web Services, for one, gives lower rates for a commitment of one or three years, which narrows the gap and gives up some of the flexibility.
Where the data sits
Cloud providers let you choose the region your data is stored in, and Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud each list regions in Australia. The Directorate advises using cloud services, support staff included, located in countries that suit the sensitivity of your data. If you hold personal information, the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner’s guidelines say a business that discloses it to an overseas recipient can be held accountable for how that recipient handles it. Ask where the data and the backups are kept, and get the answer in writing.
You can do both
The decision is made one job at a time. An office can keep email and files in the cloud and still run one application on a small server in the comms cupboard, because that application needs it. Running both is a reasonable place to stop, and nothing forces you to finish the move.
Questions to ask before you decide
- Does the maker of each application support it in the cloud?
- Is the internet connection fast and reliable enough, and what happens on the day it is down?
- Who backs up the data, how often, and can you restore it yourself?
- Which region is the data stored in?
- What does it cost over the years you would have kept a server, with support and backup counted on both sides?
- How would you get your data out again if you changed provider?
Do not skip the backup question on the assumption that the provider has it covered. The Directorate’s guidance asks it first: does the provider back up your data, or do you need to? Our lesson on the 3-2-1 backup rule explains what a safe set of copies looks like. If you would like the options compared for your own business before you commit money, that is what IT Consulting is for. The work itself is described under Cloud Services.
Sources
- SP 800-145: The NIST Definition of Cloud Computing (NIST) csrc.nist.gov
- Cloud shared responsibility model: guidance for individuals and small and medium businesses (Australian Signals Directorate) cyber.gov.au
- Shared responsibility in the cloud (Microsoft Learn) learn.microsoft.com
- Shared Responsibility Model (Amazon Web Services) aws.amazon.com
- Shared responsibilities and shared fate on Google Cloud (Google Cloud) docs.cloud.google.com
- AWS Pricing (Amazon Web Services) aws.amazon.com
- Digital tools for business (business.gov.au) business.gov.au
- What happens in a power blackout? (nbn) nbnco.com.au
- Australian Privacy Principles guidelines, Chapter 8: APP 8 Cross-border disclosure of personal information (OAIC) oaic.gov.au
- AWS Regions (Amazon Web Services) docs.aws.amazon.com
- List of Azure regions (Microsoft Learn) learn.microsoft.com
- Regions and zones (Google Cloud) docs.cloud.google.com